A small white commuter ferry crosses calm Bayshore water on a pale November morning, with tawny shoreline grasses at the edge of the frame.

Commuting From Middletown by Ferry or Train: What Each Costs This Fall

Until November 2, no ferry left Belford at 5:15 on a Monday morning. That trip now runs Monday through Thursday, along with a new 6:15 p.m. return from Pier 79. Both were added after Monmouth County officials met with NY Waterway about delays on the route, NJ.com reported.

That is how the timetable works on the Bayshore side of Middletown Township. Monmouth County owns the Belford Ferry Terminal at 10 Harbor Way, and the county picks the company that runs the boats. Trains at Middletown station run on NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line. If you work in Manhattan and are choosing between homes near the terminal in Belford, Leonardo or Port Monmouth and homes within reach of the station, the fare gap matters less than how the schedule is set and when the last trip home leaves.

What each commute costs a month this fall

Start with the fares. NY Waterway lists the same fares on both Belford routes, to Pier 11/Wall Street and to Midtown at West 39th Street. NJ Transit's fares from Middletown went up 3% on July 1, 2026, according to NJ.com.

Posted fares and parking Belford ferry, NY Waterway Middletown station, NJ Transit
Adult one-way $23 $18.50
Multi-ride $220 for 10 trips Monthly pass only listed here
Monthly pass $676 $541
Parking Free, about 1,000 spaces Lot 1: $375 a year; Lot 2: $6 a day
Manhattan arrival Pier 11/Wall Street, Brookfield Place, West 39th Street New York Penn Station

Middletown station's Lot 1 has 1,343 spaces at $375 a year for residents and nonresidents alike, and NJ Transit lists Middletown Township as the contact. Lot 2 has 245 spaces at $6 a day. A rider with a monthly train pass and a Lot 1 permit pays about $572 a month. A ferry rider with a monthly pass pays $676 and parks free. That puts the ferry about $104 a month ahead, or roughly $1,245 over a year at current fares.

On a house in a county where the October 2026 median single-family sale price was $844,450, according to NJ REALTORS' Monmouth County report, that yearly gap is small. The bigger questions are where each ride lets you off and who decides the schedule. The ferry puts you downtown or on the far west side of Midtown. The train puts you at Penn Station, and NJ Transit says most Coast Line trains from Middletown run direct, with no change of trains.

The Belford schedule is set by a county contract

The Belford route has changed operators twice in four years. NY Waterway ran it for about 20 years. In 2022 the county rejected NY Waterway's bid and awarded the terminal to SeaStreak, and NY Waterway went to court. In April 2024, Patch reported that an appellate court had ordered the county to reject the bids and open bidding again. SeaStreak kept the boats running in the meantime, so riders never lost service.

The new bidding produced the current arrangement. On August 14, 2026, the Monmouth County Board of County Commissioners announced a contract with NY Waterway starting September 8, 2026. It runs two years, with two one-year renewal options. Commissioner Director Thomas A. Arnone said the NY Waterway proposal would give residents "more rides available at a lower cost." The Monmouth Journal reported that the base fare came in only 25 cents below SeaStreak's.

For someone buying near the terminal, this means the timetable, the boats and the transfer options can change when the contract does. The base term is two years from September 8, 2026, and the county decides on any renewal after that. A house on the Bayshore side will outlast several contract cycles.

How the route has run since September 8

NY Waterway first brought back the schedule it ran before 2022. In an October 27 letter to riders, company president Armand Pohan wrote that "certain changed conditions have made it nearly impossible for us to do a 90-minute round trip between Belford and multiple stops in Manhattan," NJ.com reported. He pointed to dredging in the Belford channel, more ferry traffic at Brookfield Place than in 2020, and work at Pier 11. The company added the early Monday departure and the 6:15 p.m. Pier 79 return, and it is installing a boat-tracking system that shows departures in real time.

Riders pushed for those changes. In October, a petition with 500 signatures asked the county to review the service and to consider bringing SeaStreak back, according to NJ.com. The county gave NY Waterway 30 days, starting November 1, to show sustained improvement. Arnone said the county would move to end the contract if the company failed to meet its obligations. That review period is still open this week. If you are planning a commute from Belford, check NY Waterway's live schedule and app before counting on any morning departure, because the early trips moved again in November.

Plan around the last trip home

Morning ride time gets most of the attention, though on the nights you work late the last boat home counts for more. Under the November schedule, a Belford departure is due at Pier 11 about 40 minutes later. NY Waterway's route pages list the last weekday Wall Street return at 7:00 p.m. and the last direct Midtown return at 6:15 p.m. The commuter who organized the petition told NJ.com that a 7 p.m. last departure doesn't cover anyone who works late, has a business dinner or wants an evening in Manhattan.

The later boats go to the other side of the harbor. SeaStreak still runs from Highlands and Atlantic Highlands, with New York departures home at 7:45, 8:40 and 10:45 p.m., according to commuters quoted by NJ.com. SeaStreak's current schedule page lists a $29 adult one-way flex fare and a $240 10-trip card, plus a temporary fuel surcharge of about 5%. Daytime parking is free at both ports, and the winter schedule took effect November 9, 2026. Riders have asked for a shuttle between Atlantic Highlands and Belford, like the one SeaStreak used to run, so they could take a late boat and get back to cars parked at Belford.

If two or three late nights a week are normal for you, compare homes that are close to Belford with homes that are an easy drive to both Belford and the Highlands ports. A Bayshore address can keep both ferry options open. If your office is closer to Penn Station than to the Financial District, Middletown station and the Lot 1 permit probably decide it, whatever the ferry fare.

How this fits the rest of the county market

Monmouth County's October 2026 numbers show the trade-off isn't only about single-family homes. The NJ REALTORS report puts the townhouse-condo median sale price at $644,376 for October 2026, up 17.2% from a year earlier, with 32 days on market and 3.0 months of supply. Single-family homes sold for a median of $844,450 that month, up 7.7%, at 100.7% of list price after a median of 35 days on market.

At those prices, a few hundred dollars a year in fares or parking shouldn't decide where you buy. The schedule matters more, including how early the first trip leaves, how late the last one comes home, and whether the route is run by a transit agency or under a contract the county can rebid. For a broader look at the county, our Monmouth County neighborhood guide and our earlier post on planning a move-up purchase in Monmouth County are good next reads.

Common questions from Middletown commuters

Is parking at the Belford Ferry Terminal free? Yes. NY Waterway advertises free parking with about 1,000 spaces at Belford, and Monmouth County owns the terminal and the lots around it.

Do Middletown trains need a transfer to reach New York? NJ Transit says most Coast Line trains from Middletown run direct to Penn Station. The shuttle transfer it describes applies to stations between Bay Head and Long Branch, south of Middletown.

Does the Belford ferry run on weekends? Yes. The county's announcement lists three Belford departures a day on weekends, with two evening returns from Manhattan and no Paulus Hook service on weekends.

When does the county's 30-day review of the ferry end? The review began November 1, 2026, so it runs into the first days of December.

If your search keeps coming back to Belford versus the station, MaryBeth Tomaro would be glad to talk through both commutes with you against the homes on your list before you make an offer. Schedule a free consultation, and bring your office address and the time you usually head home.

Discover the Difference

Experience the difference that exceptional service and results can make in your real estate journey. MaryBeth is dedicated to providing personalized attention and expert guidance to each client, ensuring that your unique needs are met with the highest standards of professionalism.

Follow Me on Instagram